Appraise DomainAppraisal.pro

[hakita]

Hi,

Domainappraisal .pro is a new tool that help making domain appraisal generic, IDN free, domain names with common TLDs.

Please, let me know hwat you think about it.
Regards

[kengreenwood]

once again hakita - we've gone over this in another thread. if the site offered some tools other than the ridiculously simplistic (and entirely inaccurate) appraisal estimation tool, it might be something people would use.

Type in aol.com and you'll get a response that there isn't enough search criteria to make the domain valuable.

[Doc Com]

It's a shame you went to all the trouble to set up a site and use a .pro name.

GoDaddy reseller accounts will do the same thing.

swiftappraisal dot com

That is an automated tool

I can easily manipulate all the fields to my liking

An automated tool is great for noobs to put in some domain and then ask 49,000 $$$ for it on ebay.

domainappraisal. pro

Appraisal value between:
7 and 22$
Search volume: 2
Earning: 3
Easy to sell:
very difficult

Appraisal value between:
7 and 22$

The concept and the domain is very difficult to sell on this forum.

Take it to another forum and see what they have to say.

[hakita]

...
Type in aol.com and you'll get a response that there isn't enough search criteria to make the domain valuable.

Hi,

Aol is not a generic Word. In fact Aol is a brand.
As explain in homepage, domain appraisal is limited to generic words.

Here are examples:

Generic word : car, hotel, lyrics ... those words can be found in a Dictionary.

NON generic word : google, yahoo, aol those words are brand...

Domainappraisal.pro do not suport cybersquatting, so there is no brand domain appraisal. This is a choice.

Another important point : Domainappraisal.pro appraise naked domaine only. domaine only mean without service, without website. In other words, its like the domain was NOT used.

I can understand that you get a bad opinion of a tool you do not understand the use and goal.


But, you you need to figure out what domain have to more potential between menshoes.com or womenshoes.com Domainappraisal.pro will be able help you.

...we've gone over this in another thread

Kengreenwood this actual thread has been created before the toher one you are talking about.

Hey, Kengreenwood, what you think about this appraisal :
http://domainappraisal.pro/estimatio...ine=forums.com

Could you explain me how an "entirely inaccurate" tool could give pretty accurate result like the one bellow ?

Regards

It's a shame you went to all the trouble to set up a site and use a .pro name.

I like .pro, and can not aford domainappraisa.com

An automated tool is great for noobs to put in some domain and then ask 49,000 $$$ for it on ebay.

Automated tool does not provide market price as is. All appraisal have to be humanly updated and validated.

On other side, my tool appraise domainappraisa.com for 1200$, the actual owner ask me for 100 000$.
And you ? Honestly ? how much would you appraise domainappraisal.com ? ( < 3000 exact search a month, src : Gg kw )

domainappraisal.pro
Appraisal value between: 7 and 22$
Easy to sell: very difficult

Personnaly, i would not have spent more for this naked domain. Would you ?

The concept and the domain is very difficult to sell on this forum.
Take it to another forum and see what they have to say.

Done already, it s always interesting to compare point of view.
My conclusion is that, for now:
Pure domainer are mostly against the simple idea of automation about appraisal. The bad point is that many give review without even trying.

End user (people who buy domain for real use, not resell) are mostly happy, and give good review...
Anyway, there is a real need. Friday, more than 50 000 domaine have been appraised on DomainAppraisal.pro

[mdurrant]

Actually, AOL without the current brand as a 'naked domain', is a triple premium highly brandable 3 letter .com. A good automated appraisal tool should at the very -least- take length into account.

Your script seems nice but won't win over many people without properly approaching the art of domain appraisals. Value isn't found simply in generic words, but many factors.

[kengreenwood]

Actually, AOL without the current brand as a 'naked domain', is a triple premium highly brandable 3 letter .com. A good automated appraisal tool should at the very -least- take length into account.

Your script seems nice but won't win over many people without properly approaching the art of domain appraisals. Value isn't found simply in generic words, but many factors.

Thank you...that was my point exactly. I know that AOL is not a generic keyword. Any domainer knows that. The point is that the domain - even without the history of the brand AOL - is a premium 3 letter .com. And any domain value estimator that cannot realize that is entirely inaccurate.

[hakita]

Thank you...that was my point exactly. I know that AOL is not a generic keyword. Any domainer knows that. The point is that the domain - even without the history of the brand AOL - is a premium 3 letter .com. And any domain value estimator that cannot realize that is entirely inaccurate.

Hi all,

Yes, it does take domain lenght into account, specially LLL.tld domain, but as AOL is not into a dictionnary, it just refuse to give appraisal for that one.

For example : CAR.COM



"...Pro: Short domain name ( LLLL.tld ): Value increased..."

Or course, car.com is a great domain, not just because it is 3 letter long, but bacause "car" is massively searched.

Same for TIT.com


Same for XXX.com


An so on...

One of the biggest compagny in domain industry contacted me yesterday...
Things could evolve

Best regards

[Albert Tai]

Appraisal error:

dnforum.com : their is not enough people searching for "dnforum" on the internet for us to make an appraisal.


???

[kengreenwood]

Albert - tsk, tsk...you should know that dnforum is not a generic keyword.

[Albert Tai]

Albert - tsk, tsk...you should know that dnforum is not a generic keyword.

I r nub?

[kengreenwood]

i was being sarcastic.

[Albert Tai]

i was being sarcastic.

I told you I r nub :(
Stop playing mind tricks on me
Nooo my head hurts

I know the site its a really bad tool. I can't put anything in there and get a price unless its god damn famous.
I put many domains and it just shows up with $0 but if dnforum was going to be sold without forum just the domain (assume 0 traffic etc) it wouldn't be $0

This tool isn't going to get popular because ebay people won't use a tool that can't even appraise a domain they own.
~Al

[hakita]

Albert - tsk, tsk...you should know that dnforum is not a generic keyword.

Hello kengreenwood,

If you go on Google Keyword, you will found out there is only 1 600 exact search on "dnforum" per month.
Man, this is very little, and i can not make an appraisal based on that.

If you try with "forum" , there is much more search volume and it is possible to make an appraisal.

The big idea behind is that value is related to search volume.
In other word, the more it is searched, the more it has value.

But, in the other site, the less it is searched, the less it has value.

if you take "cat-pie.com", well, there is less search volume than "apple pie"
it COULD mean that people prefer eating apple to cat. this is choice.

So from my point of view, "apple-pie.com" have more value than "cat-pie.com"

That being said, thing can change, and the sweet cat flesh could gain in popularity. If that happe, "cat-pie.com" appraisal would increase.

In conclusion, if nobody search for it, i just can appraise it. this is one of the limit of automatic appraisal.
Best regards

This tool isn't going to get popular because ebay people won't use a tool that can't even appraise a domain they own.
~Al

You have a point Albert Tai.
Many domain have a value that is not based on pure search volume. Those domain can not be appraised.
Appraisal tool is a tool that is good for all situation.

For my part, i do buy domain name, but always generic domain with high search volume.
I exclusivly buy non english domain which are cheap and will get high value in the future. For those domain my appraisal tool is very usefull to me.

Regards