
Originally Posted by
Mark T.
To make clear, I am no forum Guru, but I have had/been involved with various forums for a dozen years easy. Also know I am no DNF expert and I cant speak what is good for DNF or not.
But,...
I speak for myself, but what forums I do patronize I patronize for specific reasons. Sure I guess it is good to want to have loose non-niche bantor with freinds of any particular site, but I feel that too much of a broad spectrum tangent being attached to a niche can (and imho, eventually will) damage a community.
I am myself tightening ship on some of my forums and reducing catagory scope to focus on niche subject.
I look at this from two ways,..
1 - I dont go to massive "topic-for-everything" forums to interact with domain name professionals or find valid information and insight, and I might expect a DN forum to have a lounge or two for member groups. But I feel the politics section here at DNF is too toxic (maybe too strong a word) for the community to grow with.
2 - The forum industry and traffic for them are in a contraction, and all traffic should be selected for quality not solely quantity. If someone using google might find a politics post in their search results, ends up coming to DNF just to have fun in the politics section. How does that benefit DNforum.com and its primary niche focus? And in fact, having a politics forum and as a result links in search engines, that provide a confused message to the random visitor that found DNF in search results of political posts? And this traffic doesnt convert well for DNF except for maybe an accidental inadvertant one-time ad-click.
For me personally, it is an un-needed distraction here.
Bookmarks