DNForum - Domain Sales, Domain Forum, Domain Appraisals, Domain Registrars - View Single Post - Lousy UDRP Decision

**Josh** · 08-01-2006, 03:12 AM

Brett,

David Sorkin mighta voted for ya. Picking the panels is at least 90% of a UDRP win. And if Sorkin doesn't vote for ya, then frankly, no one will.

It's pretty stunning they would conclude: "CLUB REWARDS is not generic and that it is the exclusive property of Complainant"

Yet, Google shows 7.8 million+ third party uses of the "club rewards" term, EVEN after you subtract out Diner's Club, all of its other spellings, and websites.

What should prove interesting is the verdict in the ClubRewards.com pending Arb Forum complaint. If it's contradictory to this decision, then it will be like the contradictory AmericanEagleStore.com and AmericanEagleStores.com decisions

08-01-2006, 03:12 AM	#7 (permalink)
Josh Gold Lifetime Member Last Online: 09-27-2008 10:32 PM iTrader: (0) Join Date: Jul 2002 Posts: 26 DNF$: 238 Location: Tennessee	Re: Lousy UDRP Decision - Clubrewardswireless.com Brett, David Sorkin mighta voted for ya. Picking the panels is at least 90% of a UDRP win. And if Sorkin doesn't vote for ya, then frankly, no one will. It's pretty stunning they would conclude: "CLUB REWARDS is not generic and that it is the exclusive property of Complainant" Yet, Google shows 7.8 million+ third party uses of the "club rewards" term, EVEN after you subtract out Diner's Club, all of its other spellings, and websites. What should prove interesting is the verdict in the ClubRewards.com pending Arb Forum complaint. If it's contradictory to this decision, then it will be like the contradictory AmericanEagleStore.com and AmericanEagleStores.com decisions Last edited by Josh; 08-01-2006 at 03:50 AM..