Very interesting discussion all around. It's good to see different people's opinions about these things. In the end, I think what makes a domain valuable is the audience and the limited availability of keywords that someone would like to use for marketing purposes...therefore, unless something is a TM or someone wants an exact name (such as a birth name or common name) then multiple domains of that keyword should be equally as valuable to someone with good marketing skills - provided that they are available for sale for the right price
