Well, you people need to get real with the appraisals. Anyone can theoretically get lucky and sell a name to an end-user for big money, but this is NOT the type of name that you can make a big score on. It doesn't make a big impression when you look at it. Even a small city name would have the chance of being sold for a large sum. This name does not have huge upside, no matter what. Go ahead and appraise with best-case scenario analysis. It doesn't mean anything in the real world where people spend real money. I bet the OP paid a ton less than you are appraising, so obviously the seller thought less about it than you guys do.
This name is decent. It is not close to a five-figure name. I bet that nobody sent PM's to the OP offering what they appriased, either. That is what usually happens when someone posts a really good name. It is a decent name with not a lot of great potential. What kind of site would you put on this? It doesn't make sense. Idle means weakness, or laziness, or idling a car. It is therefore not a strong term. And, if you ever put out a radio ad for the name 50 percent of the people would think idol.
Whatever you guys are ready to pay out of pocket RIGHT NOW for the name is what it is worth. All of the pipe dreams aabout best-case scenarios don't work for a name like this. It might work for a real estate name, or a strong financial or gambling term. You can bet the OP has not received substantial offers for this name. Nobody is sitting around daydreaming about owning it.