Best place to hire for a custom template.

[fischermx]

I need to redesign my website. I want someone to create a template in PSD for my site, including a logo. I don't need the CSS to be made by the designer since this is a custom made website and I would be doing the slicing and the rest of the work.
I'm hesitating to either go to a free lancers site and get some quotes or look design companies.
Either option has its pros and cons.
What would you do?