A six figure sale and multiple five figure sales within 30 months of when I stareted in 2005. So, if you are refering to me being one of the failures and appraising low, then that is your problem. You probably forget that you bought two names out of my sales thread just two night's ago.
The botton line is that the names aren't strong. If you think they are then step up to the plate and offer him anywhere near what your not relevant comparisons suggest. Lastly, if you were not talking about me, I apologize, but you are still wrong to suggest that those who appraise low on this set of names are failures. I would wager that these names have never received a significant offer, and the OP is wondering if he really has the gems he thinks he has. These are the types of names that can really fool you into thinking you have something that you don't really have.
When someone steps up with a real money offer for these names of $2,500 to $5,000, like you say they are worth here, then that will be the starting point as to the value. If you aren't ready to spend your own money right now.....at least 2.5K, then your appraisal is just talk. If you have PM's him an offer of at least that amount then I will give say that you have a better idea on these names than I do.
*the exceptional businesses of our esteemed moderators