• Welcome to DNForum.com - Domain Investor Forum, Free Domain Marketplace and a community for 45k+ domain pros
    If you are new to domains and looking to buy, sell and learn about domains then you have come to the right place. DNForum is the oldest global domain name community on the internet and continues to grow every day. There are over 45,000 domainers on DNForum doing everything from buying domains, selling domains, using our free in-house built tools, learning about domains and discussing domains. Take a minute and Register.

For Sale For those that want to have debate about OV values

Status
Not open for further replies.

AmericanBulldog

DNF Regular
Legacy Exclusive Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2005
Messages
544
Reaction score
0
I can tell you that I have a portfolio of names, most had an OV score <35 and they provide a great ROI, I renew over 90% of the domains I reg. This is not personal opinion, this is fact.

Another fact, I have picked up names in the OV threads that make me money and have given away names that make others money.

I scan millions of domain names and pick the ones that are a good fit for me, I pass on the rest and perhaps they benefit others.
 
In your post above, you mention your ROI on domains with OVT score less than 35, are you referring to OVT with Ext? Because my theory is only related to OVT with Ext., and only when it is 25-25. If it it 0-24 then my theory doesn't apply.

You also mentioned in the other thread that people could debate both sides all day... Sorry, I didn't notice anyone saying that they disagreed with my theory... The question isn't whether domains with OVT score 25-35 will give bad ROI, the question is only whether OVT with Ext. scores of 25-35 are mostly invalid. Do you disagree?

And for the benefit of people picking up this topic half-way, here is the summary of my theory from the other thread :

Have you noticed that the vast majority of domains in this thread have scores between 25-35? Co-incidence?

I know this isn't a discussion thread, but I believe this is very relevant to anyone reading this thread - Overture scores between 25-35 are not valid. That's just my theory, and it's a generalization - sometimes they probably are valid. But in a lot of cases (or perhaps the vast majority of cases), I believe a score around 30 is due to a script that is auto-searching once per day (= 30/month). Don't ask me who's running these scripts, could be a registrar or someone interested in the domain, or software that is checking ranking, or many other possible reasons.

I have noticed the same thing with keywords, not just with domains. I have spent a LOT of time researching keywords and keyphrases on overture and wordtracker, and there are a LOT of keyphrases that co-incidentally have scores between 25-35 even though the keyphrase is extremely rare and composed of words that do not belong together - almost definitely because someone has a script to check their ranking with those keywords.

Sorry if this has been discussed elsewhere - I haven't seen it. If someone feels this needs to be discussed further then feel free to start another thread, discussion probably doesn't belong here - I just wanted to let people know since buying domains based on invalid OVT scores will most likely result in zero-traffic domains. I know that might be obvious to most people, for example look at an example from the previous list - trueedgemonsters.com has a score of 26, even though the domain has virtually zero backlinks, no type-in traffic, and zero OVT score with 'trueedgemonsters' and 'true edge monsters'. Obviously the OVT with extension score is not valid. Of course most people would do research before buying...

and

Yes, I'm not suggesting that these domains are worthless or definitely not good - just that the OVT score is not valid.

Because from a completely logical viewpoint, if a domain has an OVT score with ext. of 30, then you would expect at least 1 visitor a day, but in reality you're likely to get 0 visitors a day, because the OVT score was false and NOBODY was really searching for the domain with extension, it was just some sort of bot or script. But the domain may get daily visitors for some other reason, eg. it may have backlinks or it may rank well for some keyword/phrase. And it may still be good for developing. But the OVT with ext. score is worthless.

I do believe this only applies to scores between 25-35. Personally, I think the thread should be changed to only show scores over 35, otherwise people are getting 'ripped off'. Of course it always comes down to 'buyer beware' and people should do research before buying, so you could argue that it's up to the buyer and nobody is trying to rip anybody off, but in fact if people highly suspect that the results are invalid then it's not really ethical to accept DNF$ from unwitting buyers who don't have that knowledge. That's just my personal opinion, I could be completely wrong :greenroll:
 
There is no doubt in my mind that most of the lists posted now are false overture scores , as soon as new drop lists get posted these scores appear the following month , I think its people looking for possible indexed pages or something when checking drop lists that creates the scores. However, occasionally there is an actual typo that gets posted with a real ovt score , so I keep looking anyhow :)

I know someone that bought about 30 off these lists and got ziltch for traffic , he was grabbing the ones with the highest scores I think , but they were just drop list names with false scores.
 
A1, let me make it clear then, I disagree, and per the domains I have selected, I know you are wrong as they bring in an excellent ROI.

Yes, I am discussing ov w/ext, and I am only talking of US overture scores, so 0-24 does not apply as you can't see US OV scores under 25.

I do think you need to do your research and not just register names because of the score. Look for backlinks, look for keywords, look for typos, look for popular trends and names, try and see a reason why someone may type in the domain.

I post only the names I don't register, for whatever reason, I have not seen value in them, it does not mean there is no value in them or not value for others.

There are a number of folks who frequent these lists and consistently register names, although they have not chimed in, I am sure they don't continually register losers, so there must be a reason.

Some names only get a trickle of traffic, but they are good keywords and generate great revenue per click, some get consistent daily traffic but only make a few pennies per click. I prefer traffic domains rather than buy and hold waiting for a buyer.

I guess it depends on your perception of value as much as anything, If I reg a domain for $7 and it earns $8 in a year that'a 15% ROI, that's pretty good. Most do considerably better, some do worse. A domain that earns $20 in a year is providing a whopping 185% ROI.

This is not a get rich quick scheme, not even a get rich slow scheme, but it can provide a consistent good ROI across a broad range of direct navigation websites. You can take some of the better ones and turn them into mini sites to get them indexed and increase your returns dramatically.

Bottom line for me is I find them with an OV w/ext score, most are under 35 as you tend to compete with the domain snappers for higher scores.
 
to summarize the rant below:
OVT score != great domain.
OVT score + some other positive indications and factors == great domain.

the rant:
Any one who buys domains solely on overture score (especially in the 25-35 range) is bound to lose.

There is a rare gem or two in these overture with extension threads, and they are appropriately snapped up quickly. The point is that these names are "gems" because they not only have overture with ext., but also have several other factors in their favor. Bulldog said it best when saying "I post only the names I don't register, for whatever reason, I have not seen value in them". He doesn't see value because he's not looking at only OVT score. Otherwise, he would reg every OVT name he finds. There is no need for debate.

For me, an overture domain will get traffic for many reaons, primarily if it's a typo or a dictionary word (which happens... some people fail to realize certain domains are dictionary words in other languages).

IMHO, any name with OVT that doesn't have traffic is "invalid". Again, invalid is really a silly term because any score is valid by the nature of validity. But, if you define "validity" to mean a correspondence to traffic figures, then yes, most 25-35 names are invalid.

I can easily imagine a piece of software that wants to track if your listed with yahoo daily, and once a day types your domain into yahoo (overture) to make sure. Depending on how overture tracks unique searchers, this can lead to a 28-31 score for just about any old name.

bottom line:
OVT score is a great place to START in finding value amongst a large list of names. It's usually the first or second filter I apply to a large set of domains to weed out all the garbage. Once a list is scrubbed to only OVT domains, I then look for some other positive indication that the overture score means something and isn't just garbage.
 
Mike,

I agree completely with you. There is always another factor in the reason I choose a name, but I know I leave good names on the table, perhaps I missed something, or wasn't looking at things quite right or perhaps simply distracted and left good names out there.

For instance most months OV names are hard to come by, this month there seems to be a spike in names with and OV w/ext score of 27 or 81 (3x27), I do not know why they are there but it is more likely I will miss a gem or two as I am already tending to ignore the 27's and 81's.
 
I am already tending to ignore the 27's and 81's.

EXACTLY! You see, you too have noticed something suspicious which seems to indicate that scores may not be entirely valid. I just thought it would be nice to educate other people who don't spend so much time looking at these things. I guess I just don't like the idea of newbies wasting money on these domains based on the scores. Sure they should do adequate research, but they DID see a decent looking OVT score, and that alone seems like a good indicator, but it's not - and that's why I brought it up - for educational purposes :-)

Regarding the question of validity : I am defining 'valid' as meaning that a human typed it into an Overture (or affiliate) search box. I define invalid as a script or bot. For example if I have a domain that is getting 1000 hits per day, but I know that traffic was just a bot, it would be unethical for me to sell the domain based on traffic since I know it's invalid. Sure, it's undeniable real traffic, no question - but the hits aren't valid, the traffic is worthless.

I agree that paying $7 for a domain and making $8/year is not a bad ROI. And as I already said, I do believe these domains may have value - I'm sure people reg names from these OVT with ext. lists and those domains get visitors and the buyer makes money, no doubt about it. My point is only that the OVT score is highly suspicious and I believe people have the right to be educated with the fact that the scores are not necessarily true, as AmericanBulldog has pointed out with the current 27/81 spike.

ps. Thanks for pointing out the suspicious 81 number, that was educational for me and I appreciate you sharing it. It's exactly that type of information that I think BELONGS in the OVT with ext. thread, since most people aren't going to see this thread.
 
bulldog, I wasn't trying to implicate you at all. I know you leave some good ones behind. I was just expanding on the discussion. In fact, I believe all the posts in this thread so far make the same point.

OVT is A factor, not THE factor, in determining whether or not to purchase names, and that is highlighted by the fact that there appears to be "invalid (as defined by A1 above)" OVT scores.
 
mikesherov said:
I can easily imagine a piece of software that wants to track if your listed with yahoo daily, and once a day types your domain into yahoo (overture) to make sure. Depending on how overture tracks unique searchers, this can lead to a 28-31 score for just about any old name.

No need to imagine it. It's not even software. All you need to do is insert a small line of code into your index page and everyday (or even more often if you wish, like hourly etc) an automated visit will occur. That code has been around for a long time. I first ran across it at least 5 yrs ago though I never used it (except as a 1 day test to see if it really works out of curiosity). It's possibly done by some dishonest sellers.
 
right... place this on your index page:

<?php
$result=file_get_contents('http://search.yahoo.com/search?p=example.com');
?>

but that assumes ovt counts once a day by the same IP as different unique seaches. to fool overture gauranteed, you'd need to build in proxies.
 
So it seems we're mostly all in agreement.

I do not think anyone has advocated just buying domains based on the OV score alone, and when asked, I always try and explain how I look for value in a domain.

There are many methods to determine value, we all choose our own ways to analyze the domains presented on this forum, wether ov w/ext or names for sale.
 
I would love to say 'yes we all agree'. But your 'agreement' is : 'Buying based purely on OVT is not smart' - and that agreement has nothing to do with the question here. To remind you, the question is 'Are OVT scores of 25-35 invalid?' That was the purpose of my post, and the only conclusion that has been reached is 'You shouldn't buy purely from OVT score' - that's a nice conclusion, but it isn't even close to an agreement on the actual question!! :-)

To put this in perspective, let's look at a recent post in the OVT with ext. thread :

I reg paulabwhite.com. I have no idea who she is though. :)

There is no doubt that people in that thread are buying based purely on OVT score, with no other research. Sure, we can sit back and let them learn from experience... After all, it's only their money that's potentially going down the drain - and they probably have plenty of disposable income, so we should just let them spend it - we may have knowledge that could help them make a better choice, but let's keep quiet and keep the secret to ourselves? After all, they could get lucky and have traffic and make money, right?

I don't think there's any way we can prove one way or the other that these scores are created by humans or bots. As AmericanBulldog pointed out, he's seen plenty of 81 scores recently - and it's quite possible that it's just coincidental and humans are searching exactly 81 times for each domain recently. I can't prove otherwise. But I do think that potential buyers (or potential DNF$ donators) deserve to know about suspiciously non-human-like results...

I was never accusing anybody of anything, I was just pointing out the scoring anomaly that I'd noticed - but since AmericanBulldog seems to disagree with me, I would like to ask - since you noticed the 81 mystery, and you have started ignoring domains with that score, would you feel comfortable accepting DNF$ from people when they reg domains with that score? Sure, they could get lucky, there could be traffic - but if you had knowledge which seemed to indicate that the score wasn't created from human searches, wouldn't you feel obligated to point that out? Or are you a firm believer in 'buyer beware'? I really am sorry to point the question directly at you, but you do seem intent on making my question seem irrelevant...
 
A1, you are posting opinion, I have given you fact. I have many domains, with OV w/ext scores under 35 that provide good ROI. Without looking at every domain I have, I would easily guess that 85% of the OV w/ext scores are under 35.

My opinion is that we don't see many of the other OV w/ext >35 because they are being snapped by pool, snapbacks etc...

I have in fact posted here and in the exclusive thread my skepticism of the 27/81 names, and yes, if you feel there is a name there worth registering and you are going to spend money registering it, then I feel justified in requesting the obligotary donation.

Let me share some examples of '06 earnings:
domain A registered Jan 4/06 240 visitors 106 clicks earnings $21.92 OV w/ext 26
domain B registered 30 Dec/06 179 visitors 32 clicks earnings $24.31 OV w/ext 26
domain C registered 31 Dec/06 953 visitors 202 clicks earnings $29.19 OV w/ext 26

These are just 3, reg'd within a few days of each other, all with similar dollar earnings, wildly varying visitors and CTR's all OV w/ext 26, all on their way to earning stellar 677% ROI at their present rates.
 
Yes you stated your 27/81 skepticism in the exclusive thread, I guess you forgot in the Platinum thread.

I don't understand why you feel the need to prove your success with domains with OVT 25-35 domains, because I have never doubted that - I have continually stated that I believe these domains can have value. I have also said the success probably is related to other factors. As you said, you do research, and if you find factors which support the OVT score then you register. Of course you have success, you're doing research. If you were just blindly impulsively registering domains based purely on OVT score without any supporting research then you'd obviously have much less success - just like quite a few of the people registering the domains that you're listing - that's why I think education is necessary and ethical. In my previous post I quoted someone who recently made it clear they are registering without research, and I have gotten a PM from someone who also is obviously registering without research - they're just looking at the OVT score and registering. I know that is not your problem, I know it is not your responsibility to hand-hold people. But you say I am stating opinion and you are stating fact - if you are skeptical of your 'facts', as you have admitted, then how is your fact better than my opinion? These 'facts' appear accurate to some people and are causing impulse buying without research. And I just wanted to let them know that that things aren't necessarily what they seem.
 
Dude, your wrong again, I did state my skepticism of the 27/81 domains in the thread before posting a large list of them. go back a few posts.

You say it is your opinion that OV w/ext scores under 35 are invalid. I say you are wrong, I have given you numbers to prove my point, and I have given you my opinion on why we do not see a lot of high OV scores in these threads.

I've said my piece, nothing more to add. Don't care to piss into the wind.
 
I'm wrong again! Oh no. Can you remind me what I was first wrong about? People agreed with my theory, so if anything it's questionable, not wrong.

I went back 100 posts before saying that you hadn't mentioned 27/81. I know you're probably very busy, but if you have time to prove me wrong please post a link directly to the post where you mentioned it.

And the numbers you have used to 'prove your point' mean nothing - if you post the actual domains I'll point out the other factors which are giving the domains value - backlinks, OVT scores for the keywords without extension, etc. All you've proven is that some domains have value. I think we all knew that.
 
First your wrong that OV scores w/ext <35 are invalid.

Second, Here's the whole post brother....made yesterday at 10:53 AM



Thanks for donations received...here's a list of 70 domains. As previously mentioned I do not know why there are an abundace of 27 and 81 scores.
Donation still required if testing.

aloeempire.com 33
blastbilard.com 32
copsnola.com 27
copyrightcouriers.com 27
coreyjmiller.com 27
corpcoach.net 27
corralesgallery.com 27
corunashipping.com 27
cosmicalbanking.com 30
countrycrochet.net 28
countrymidi.net 27
countrypineappleinn.com 39
countrytreasureswood.com 28
courybpg.com 27
daozu.com 32
easternelement.com 29
flpaper.com 39
lansuo.com 33
lisavangordonderrico.com 42
lowespa.com 28
loyalsecurities.com 27
lpnjobfinder.com 27
ltdcoformations.com 27
ltwhisky.com 27
luandjo.com 27
lucasjacksonrecruitment.com 27
luciedamien.com 27
luckydogoutfitters.com 27
luggageheadquarters.com 27
lugmail.net 27
lukachfamily.net 27
luqiaoly.com 27
micheledevita.net 27
michelesimons.com 26
michellebryan.com 29
michellehamiltonhomes.com 27
michiganlandman.com 27
midcoastmaintenance.com 27
midcoastmaintenance.com 27
midlifecoachingforwomen.com 27
midnightclubtv.com 27
mikeanddeann.com 27
mikefawcett.com 27
mikrorinoplasty.net 27
milanv.com 27
militaryenterprise.com 27
millstreetantiques.com 27
mindstomedia.com 27
mingbei.com 27
mirroredimages.net 27
mirroredimages.net 27
missingcoach.com 27
missyandbill.com 28
mistressnorthstar.com 27
mitratechnology.com 27
qcaonlinestore.com 41
rbisbeebisbeelaw.com 34
reboundrocks.com 25
sangxin.com 27
sejiang.com 28
shomenow.com 28
siyorkrite.com 81
sylkydiva.com 49
thebestteendance.com 81
tulsabrandu.com 30
whitejane.com 28
whiteravennumerology.com 27
whjys.com 27
whjys.com 27
wholesaleonwww.com 27

nuff said. You will not be swayed by numbers, I will not be swayed by your opinion. I think we can only agree to disagree.
 
As I said, you're probably busy. So I took the time to compile a text file containing every single word that you have posted in the OVT thread. You posted around 20,000 lines since February, I then removed duplicates and it came down to around 5000 lines (wow you sure repeat yourself a lot ;) )

Since February, the number 81 has only appeared in 7 lines of your posts. They are :

118118UK.COM
118118uk.com 45
mike81.net
mike81.net 39
siyorkrite.com 81
Thanks for donations received...here's a list of 70 domains. As previously mentioned I do not know why there are an abundace of 27 and 81 scores.
thebestteendance.com 81

As you can see, you wrote 'As previously mentioned I do not know why there are an abundace of 27 and 81 scores.' But you obviously didn't 'previously mention' it, otherwise it would have appeared in one of the other 6 lines containing the number 81.

So then, I will accept your apology in the form of a DNF$ donation. Just kidding, I don't want any part of the DNF$ from those poor suckers that donated ;) Hehe hey just kidding, if you mention pissing then I can make a joke, right?

So, please state your skepticism in the thread, then you will have completed your ethical responsibility to inform people of your doubt in these scores, and I will be quiet so you won't need to keep telling me I'm wrong when I just proved you wrong. I even already gave you the opportunity to make it right, I said you probably just forgot to mention it in the Premium thread... Oh well, I guess maybe next time you'll check before accusing people.

I think we can only agree to disagree.

No, I'm pretty sure we can agree that you're wrong. At least about your claim to mentioning your skepticism in the Premium thread.
 
I don't have as much time as you seem to...

11:23 am July 17 exclusive thread:
Odd results this month, lots of 27 and several scores of 81 (3x27), I am not confident that these (27's and 81's) are good scores. As usual, do your due diligence, check over and see if they have value to you.
 
Doh! Sorry yes I said 'Exclusive' in my post, when obviously I meant Platinum. This thread was created and linked from the Platinum thread. It was the Platinum thread that only had 7 lines with the number 81, and it was the Platinum thread where you said you have previously mentioned the 81 skepticism. Sorry I accidentally wrote Exclusive in the previous post, obviously that was wrong and I've edited it for clarity. It should have been obvious to YOU that I was talking about Platinum, because EVERYTHING has been about the Platinum thread so far...

So... You wrote in the Platinum thread that you previously mentioned the 81 skepticism, and you didn't. So then, are you going to finally write it in the Platinum thread, or do you want to continue debating why you don't need to inform people in the Platinum thread.

First your wrong that OV scores w/ext <35 are invalid.

I never said that. I said they are mostly invalid. You are buying based on supporting factors, so your stats don't have anything to do with the 'debate'. Now if you want to actually post a list of domains and screenshots showing 'stellar 677% ROI' and ONLY OVT scores with no other supporting factors then at least the stats would be relevant to the debate. But I don't expect you to do this, I know you don't want to continue talking about this, and I don't want you to go to the trouble of posting the relevant stats. I'm just pointing out that your stats you offered are irrelevant to the purpose of this thread - to educate people that these scores MAY be invalid due to being from non-human searches. You already admitted your skepticism in some scores, so I don't understand what you think you're debating - are you on both sides of the debate? (a good way to win :-) ) In any case, as I have continued to say - I just want the OVT thread to inform buyers of the possibility of invalid scores - and since you have said that you have already informed people of your suspicions (in the Platinum thread) when you haven't, then it seems a reasonable request.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom