Tell him $650 and then take at least $350. He won't go for other versions, either. He is either called David or Dave; not both.
How much value does BradleyPitt.com have?...as a fan site. David is his name. Don't sell if you don't need the money though. David is one of the most common names in the world, and blogging is one of the fasting growing activies. You are basically giving it away at under $1,000. Lots of people around here are used to low-balling because if you do it enough times you will strike oil. There aren't too many names in the world that are worth under $500 if the buyer actually found you. Think about it. Now,if you were trying to get out of a name by selling it on this board or Ebay,then that is another story....you might not a get a bid for $20. You won't blow the sale by asking for mid to high $$$. If he calls your bluff then sell it to him for whatever he has to spend. It is your job to pry as much out of him and complete the sale.....that's what makes it fun.