What's better? PenForum.com or PenForums.com?

[florafauna.com]

I've recently decided to build out this website into a forum. However, I don't wish to start off on the wrong foot. Would it be advisable to secure the plural PenForums.com in addition to PenForum.com? Which variant is better? Thanks in advance.

 

[RobM]

Will you have one forum or more than one? Of course it's better to have both and redirect one to the other.

 

[DomainsGENERAL.com]

Personally, I prefer the singular. I consider a "forum" to be the whole place. Some people consider sub-sections to each be a forum, making the place "forums". Different POV, probably both valid.

If you have the singular, there is no real need to also register the plural, but that's for you to decide.
The best argument would be to prevent a competing forum to be established on the plural name.

Now, they both seem registered. Maybe you have both. I would go with the singular and redirect the plural to the singular. That's only my own opinion.

PS: DNforums is for sale on afternic. Not owned by DNforum, not redirecting to it.

 

[florafauna.com]

Personally, I prefer the singular. I consider a "forum" to be the whole place. Some people consider sub-sections to each be a forum, making the place "forums". Different POV, probably both valid.

If you have the singular, there is no real need to also register the plural, but that's for you to decide.
The best argument would be to prevent a competing forum to be established on the plural name.

Now, they both seem registered. Maybe you have both. I would go with the singular and redirect the plural to the singular. That's only my own opinion.

PS: DNforums is for sale on afternic. Not owned by DNforum, not redirecting to it.

Of the two names, which one would be more appealing to end users, and which would receive more type-in traffic?

 

[RobM]

I would doubt that either receive type-in traffic but you could park them both and check statistics. I always prefer the single myself but it is subjective.

 

[Helmuts]

PenForum feels cleaner. Best!

 

[Leo2k]

Forum is the most widely used and searched word compared to Forums. You can verify it using Google trends.

Forward forums to forum.

 

[florafauna.com]

Forum is the most widely used and searched word compared to Forums. You can verify it using Google trends.

Forward forums to forum.

I own the singular, but the owner of the plural is asking for an exorbitant amount for the name. I’ve been torn whether to fork over the cash he’s asking for the plural, hence why I created this thread to ask for advice.

 

[RobM]

I wouldn't bother with the plural then. If you're going to develop the singular then you'll be generating the content and traffic. I doubt there are any typeins to the plural as 'pen forums' is not a popular term and has almost no monthly searches.

 

[DomainsGENERAL.com]

the owner of the plural is asking for an exorbitant amount for the name.

Then there is no question.

It was already feeling unneeded if it was available for handreg. But if you would have to pay a high price, clearly forget it, IMHO. Almost the only type-in traffic you'll have is people knowing about the domain, so it will happen on the one you use, advertise, etc. "Magical traffic coming from the sky" will probably be close to zero for both names.

I do agree with @RobM on the matter.
PS: To me, the most appealing is the singular in any case, as M. Overlord says it himself.

 

[MapleDots]

I own the singular, but the owner of the plural is asking for an exorbitant amount for the name. I’ve been torn whether to fork over the cash he’s asking for the plural, hence why I created this thread to ask for advice.

I am in the exact opposite situation

I own MapleDots.ca and MapleDots.com and someone purchased both singulars and is sitting on them for obvious reasons. I am very well known in the industry and I suspect the person is waiting for me to contact them.
That said I could have registered the singular version back in the day but I thought then and now that it does not impact my business at all.

My suggestion would be for you to do the same. Launch your business and worry less about the plural because there is always a misspell or something around the corner.

Fact is a huge portion of your traffic will come from google and they will index you if you do your job right.


Good luck, I'm rooting for you, I love watching new forums