• Welcome to DNForum.com - Domain Investor Forum, Free Domain Marketplace and a community for 45k+ domain pros
    If you are new to domains and looking to buy, sell and learn about domains then you have come to the right place. DNForum is the oldest global domain name community on the internet and continues to grow every day. There are over 45,000 domainers on DNForum doing everything from buying domains, selling domains, using our free in-house built tools, learning about domains and discussing domains. Take a minute and Register.

For Sale Why Are Registrars Able To Auction Expired Names??!

Status
Not open for further replies.

radioz

New Member
The Originals
Legacy Platinum Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2003
Messages
1,136
Reaction score
19
Since the domain drop scheme changed radically a couple of years back, I have been left with a hanging question and that is exactly 'WHY do registrars now have the right to auction domains that just happened to expire at their registries?' The former owner bought and paid for the domain. He simply, for whatever reason, didn't renew the name. The only case that I can imagine for the registrar then being able to take the name as their own is if the former owner transferred or bought it with a bad credit card. In that case, the registrar was owed something so I can then see the argument that they own it. If they are owed no money I cannot understand why they own it. When I let a domain expire, I cannot think of any way that I harm the registrar such that they should take ownership of my former name. It would seem that it should expire plainly and simply whether it has value or not.

If there is some logic to the registrar being able to take ownership I'd sure like someone to explain it to me. If there is any right to sell expired domains on their part and if the previous owner owes no money then why shouldn't the former owner benefit from the sale? The former owner brought the name to the registrar and likely paid at least a year of registration fees for it. Are they entitled to nothing?

Is it that legally, perhaps, a domain name is considered as having no monetary value? I come from a background in radio and there was a time that a radio or TV station construction permit or license by itself without a facility was considered as having no legal value here in the USA. Like a good domain, a license to broadcast does have value and that was eventually corrected. If a domain name has no monetary value, and domain law seems to be written with that though in mind, then registrars are going to a lot of trouble to set up their own auction sites to sell 'valueless' domains. If that is the case, this model should be corrected for the benefit of previous owners or, if we do presume that expired domain names have no intrinsic value by themselves then perhaps registrars should be prevented from selling them and they should just expire anyway.

If you move and have paid off your mortgage, the former mortgage company doesn't get to claim your old home. Only if the mortgage company is left partially or fully unpaid do they have any rights to your old house. If you let the lease lapse on a self storage shed, the storage company will sell your stuff but they will have to give you any funds left over after their fees and costs have been paid. So why does Bob Parsons get $4,915 for a domain name that recently expired at Go Daddy!

While we're at it why do registrars have the right to mass register thousands of 'valueless' domains everyday only to dump them within five days without penalty if they decide they don't want them? That's for another day though!
 
I nominate this POST OF THE WEEK! You raise some of the very best criticisms and questions around several important issues. Registrars have not been enabled or encouraged by ICANN (to engage in these activities) as much as registrars have found loopholes to exploit that ICANN did not anticipate ... and so registrars have thus assumed various controls on domains without challenge. ICANN being a slow, somewhat inept lumbering giant led to the things you mention going on for years before finally being addressed as potential abuses and violations of the spirit of the registrar agreement.

Personally, I don't think registrars should be allowed to profit via auctions on expiring domain names. However, this is permitted but without regulation or practically any guidelines by ICANN or the registries = an unwanted wild west scenario fraught with ongoing abuses and deception (no one to police these activities). Some drop-catch registrars are white collar crooks and have no business ethics whatsoever, i.e. fake auctions, shill bidding, refusing to honor auction outcomes, etc.

Registrars are not supposed to warehouse domain names as that pits them as direct competitors with the public they are serving. The ICANN registrar agreement addresses this, somewhat poorly (typical lack of ICANN foresight). However, this and "domain tasting" (another abuse) have been recently addressed in ICANN meetings. In short, the overseer, ICANN, have either failed to respond with timeliness or authority to compaints of abuses or they have deflected any responsibility where investigation and action were merited.

Funny is that unsuspecting people of all types begin to see what is occurring ... and then ask exactly the right questions. Just as you did. You get your first whiff of these nonsensical abuses and know immediately something stinks. You ask yourself "Why is this being allowed to occur?" "Who is addressing these issues?"
 
I am in total agreement with the above two posts. Indeed it would appear to me that the auctioning of 'expired domain names' is possibly not legal. Unfortunately the body charged with policing the domain name industry, ICANN, is so weak that it does not act decisively on this. All it would take is to remove the five day rule and implement a policy that all expired domain names are returned to the registraion body responsible.

I would also like to nominate the original post as 'post of the week'.
 
My understanding is that once the name has expired it's no longer yours... but you still hold a preemptive right to reclaim the domain. In the meantime the registrar will do as if it was no longer yours...
When registrar release domains they gain nothing by letting them drop.
On the other hand, by putting them to auction they can make money on the valuable ones. So it's hardly surprising godaddy, netsol and others are auctionning names. At present there is no code of conduct which would forbid doing so. Until then more and more registrars are going to resort to the practice. That's happening right now.
Also check the fine print: when using a registrar you agree to their terms which may limit your rights. Choose your registrar wisely if you don't want to see your expired names being auctioned.

It looks legal but questionable. Even ethically dubious.
Again there is a margin between legal and ethical.
There is an obvious conflict of interest for registrars but in the end money rules.

... All it would take is to remove the five day rule and implement a policy that all expired domain names are returned to the registraion body responsible.
Actually things could get even worse if verisign can have it their way with CLS etc. The danger not only comes from ICANNT itself but from the registries, which are for-profit businesses and are more proactive than ICANNT itself when it comes to money.

Also domain tasting increases the number of firm registrations. It means more $$$$$$ for verisign and ICANNT too (they levy a fee on each registration).
I don't think ICANNT is going to step up, unless they have a vested interest in doing so.
 
I have been discusted with this since it started. It should be agaist the law. Imagine being the person who registered jasmin.com...they actually let it lapse...snapnames and netsol pocket 300,000+...it is just wrong.

This will not change unless someone or some entity with a lot of money and power loses their name and lobbies to have this theft stopped.
 
WHY do registrars now have the right to auction domains that just happened to expire at their registries?
I do not think they have the right, expired domains should get dropped.
"Expired domain auctions" fell into their(registries) lap and no one is stopping them.
You raise many good points.
$$$ Bob Parsons $$$
Thread of the week, no doubt.
 
With the size of this forum, and the obvious fact that something is wrong with current Registrars.... Why don't we all put together some kind of fund to lobby against this? :grouphug:

I am more than willing to spend some time on this. I would also love to see things return to normal again.

I can barely remember the days of a SOMEWHAT level playing field.

Current practices are unethical and downright dirty.

If you can recall, GoDaddy claims they make their money by "bulk" orders, etc. But my theory is they knew this all along... They knew the cheaper they could provide Registrations for, the more people would register, and eventually a greater chance good domains would expire through them. Then, they would auction (TDNAM) their domains, and pull in a couple extra bucks. If you factor all of these auction into the big picture, they are probably making what NetSol used to get ($70/per reg) or more. Pure Genious.

The worst thing about this.... Bob Parsons was the man who cried about NetSol having too much control... and he basically ripped them a new one using the current legal system. Now, he has turned the tables on us domainers and stabbed all of us in the back. The only good that has come of this is cheaper reg fees.

It's a shame GoDaddy bailed on their IPO, because as long as this practice is going on.... I was going to keep buying their stock.... Eventually, they will go public... and I will be there to buy a good sized chunk of that damn company. Then, they will have to listen to what I have to say about things. MUHUHAHAHAH :smokin:

Not to mention I will get first dibs on super awesome expiring domains they have negelected to publicly post. ;D :bolt:
 
If there is some logic to the registrar being able to take ownership I'd sure like someone to explain it to me.

Perhaps when a domain expires, that ends it. Know one should be able to get immediate access or control. The day after it expires, it should become available to register via "live". In other words, first come, first serve, just like when you register any new domain today!! First one to click on the domain to register gets fair game..... :-(
No more fighting over and no more "CONTROL"
:fencing:
 
When Signature Domains started auctioning off names they caught years ago, everyone said they can't get away with that. Since then the registrars keep pushing the envelope. ICANN knows they can't squeeze the big bucks out of us so they let the registrars do whatever they like, knowing at some point they will get their cut.
 
but if they just dropped back for anyone and everyone to register as "fair" game, then there would be less of a monopoly of portfolio's and MORE people investing because everyone would realize they have a much better chance, thus, more portfolio shifting & more domains being registered after they expire resulting in more $$$$ for the Registrar's and everyone else
 
but if they just dropped back for anyone and everyone to register as "fair" game, then there would be less of a monopoly of portfolio's and MORE people investing because everyone would realize they have a much better chance.......

The weakness in that argument is -
"Who will catch them when they drop?"

Presently, if a quality domain drops it is caught by Pool, Snapnames or Enom.
Which, then turns into an expensive auction.

If it is a mediocre domain, it will be caught by Pool, Snapnames, Enom, GoDaddy or a domain taster.

And, the domain tasters have a number of credentials catching the drops.
Once, they test it, it will be caught by another domain taster.

I'm not happy that the different registrars are auctioning off the expiring domains.
Not that they are auctioning them off. It is because they scattered
all over the place. Enom, Snapnames, GD, etc.

Personally, I would rather it go thru the old standard process. But, things change.
So, I have to accept it and learn how to deal with the present reality.

An add'l point. Once, a domain expires, the registrar is billed for the expired domain
unless they mark it for deletion.

The old timers can tell you about the old system of expired domains. It was
up to the registrar to renew it and allow you time to pay them.

Or, the registrar could mark it for immediate deletion.

That was how Ultimate and others ended up with so many great domains.

One day you own i.e. Candy.com and the day after the expiration date,
it is owned by someone else.

Incidently, Icann initiated the 35 day wait period around Feb. 2003.

About turning back the clock, I can remember when gasoline was under $ 0.50 a gallon.

Once, you solve the Icann problem, can someone please figure out how I can buy
gasoline locally for under $ 1.00 a gallon, again.
 
GeorgeK pointed out on another forum that there's always the USDOJ Antitrust Division and that although ICANN might ignore us, it's hard to ignore the Department of Justice.

http://www.usdoj.gov/atr/contact/newcase.htm

They also might help with the variable pricing for .biz/info/org issue, we should all complain about both!
 
POST OF THE MONTH and wonderful replies!!

What do I think about it? I believe all domainers are still somewhat thought of as being lumped together with the cyber-squatters group no matter how legitimate many of us may try to be. With that being said, we're in a dirty rotten type of business, picking up the pieces of failed ventures, failed renewal management, etc. How could they then not look down upon us and completely ignore our entreaties for fairness and some form of order and consistency?
 
Great replies and I have been complaining since day 1 about drop companies auctioning off domains and making a killing. IMHO ICAAN is a corrupt entity. I suspect a lot of money gets passed under the table over there. It's like they are a new crime family or something. DOJ should seriously look into all their practices. If I accidentally dropped a name another company shouldn't benefit by selling it for THOUSANDS. That's just plain wrong. ICAAN is getting more and more bad press but I have yet to see them change for the better...only get worse.

I would think a random drop time for all domains might help curb this. Let's say 30-180 days before a name become available. Totally make it random. Also remove registrars from owning or participating in the drop scheme simply as a "conflict of interest" situation.
 
If you want to know how lucrative the business can be, just look at the S-1 from Go Daddy. Even though they decided not to go public, the S-1 cannot be retracted so it gives you a snapshot into the company's and the industries finances.

From the Go Daddy S-1:

Revenue for 2005:
Domain name registration $84,511,000
Website hosting $30,551,000
On-demand services and other revenue $24,696,000

On-Demand Services and Other Revenue:

On-Demand Services:
- online shopping cart
- website building service
- email accounts
- search engine optimization service
- email marketing service
- fax thru email service.

Other revenue sources:
- SSL certificates
- domain name appraisal
- domain reseller enrollment fees
- domain auction services
- “parked pages”

It is disappointing that the documents do not break up the revenue from these multiple streams. It would be very interesting to see what income is derived from parked pages and domain auctions.
 
Too bad they don't list the net income..

Wow godaddy makes so much yet the CEO is such a whiner in his blog.
 
Too bad they don't list the net income..

Wow godaddy makes so much yet the CEO is such a whiner in his blog.

I guess this brings me to my next question about GoDaddy...

HOW IN THE HECK have they failed to yield a profit yet? Where is all of that money going? ..... oh wait... now I know..... SUPER BOWL ADS.

Duh!

No really... where?
 
Excellent posts - I wrote about this 4+ years ago on DnForum.

If there are no rules regarding drop policies why wouldn't other registrars just create their own wls for names registered through them? They could then sell of their good names and then turn the leftovers to Verisign.

Here it is 4+ years later and we have to see any substantive improvements (outside the grace period) in the drop process.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom