- Joined
- Apr 14, 2003
- Messages
- 1,136
- Reaction score
- 19
Since the domain drop scheme changed radically a couple of years back, I have been left with a hanging question and that is exactly 'WHY do registrars now have the right to auction domains that just happened to expire at their registries?' The former owner bought and paid for the domain. He simply, for whatever reason, didn't renew the name. The only case that I can imagine for the registrar then being able to take the name as their own is if the former owner transferred or bought it with a bad credit card. In that case, the registrar was owed something so I can then see the argument that they own it. If they are owed no money I cannot understand why they own it. When I let a domain expire, I cannot think of any way that I harm the registrar such that they should take ownership of my former name. It would seem that it should expire plainly and simply whether it has value or not.
If there is some logic to the registrar being able to take ownership I'd sure like someone to explain it to me. If there is any right to sell expired domains on their part and if the previous owner owes no money then why shouldn't the former owner benefit from the sale? The former owner brought the name to the registrar and likely paid at least a year of registration fees for it. Are they entitled to nothing?
Is it that legally, perhaps, a domain name is considered as having no monetary value? I come from a background in radio and there was a time that a radio or TV station construction permit or license by itself without a facility was considered as having no legal value here in the USA. Like a good domain, a license to broadcast does have value and that was eventually corrected. If a domain name has no monetary value, and domain law seems to be written with that though in mind, then registrars are going to a lot of trouble to set up their own auction sites to sell 'valueless' domains. If that is the case, this model should be corrected for the benefit of previous owners or, if we do presume that expired domain names have no intrinsic value by themselves then perhaps registrars should be prevented from selling them and they should just expire anyway.
If you move and have paid off your mortgage, the former mortgage company doesn't get to claim your old home. Only if the mortgage company is left partially or fully unpaid do they have any rights to your old house. If you let the lease lapse on a self storage shed, the storage company will sell your stuff but they will have to give you any funds left over after their fees and costs have been paid. So why does Bob Parsons get $4,915 for a domain name that recently expired at Go Daddy!
While we're at it why do registrars have the right to mass register thousands of 'valueless' domains everyday only to dump them within five days without penalty if they decide they don't want them? That's for another day though!
If there is some logic to the registrar being able to take ownership I'd sure like someone to explain it to me. If there is any right to sell expired domains on their part and if the previous owner owes no money then why shouldn't the former owner benefit from the sale? The former owner brought the name to the registrar and likely paid at least a year of registration fees for it. Are they entitled to nothing?
Is it that legally, perhaps, a domain name is considered as having no monetary value? I come from a background in radio and there was a time that a radio or TV station construction permit or license by itself without a facility was considered as having no legal value here in the USA. Like a good domain, a license to broadcast does have value and that was eventually corrected. If a domain name has no monetary value, and domain law seems to be written with that though in mind, then registrars are going to a lot of trouble to set up their own auction sites to sell 'valueless' domains. If that is the case, this model should be corrected for the benefit of previous owners or, if we do presume that expired domain names have no intrinsic value by themselves then perhaps registrars should be prevented from selling them and they should just expire anyway.
If you move and have paid off your mortgage, the former mortgage company doesn't get to claim your old home. Only if the mortgage company is left partially or fully unpaid do they have any rights to your old house. If you let the lease lapse on a self storage shed, the storage company will sell your stuff but they will have to give you any funds left over after their fees and costs have been paid. So why does Bob Parsons get $4,915 for a domain name that recently expired at Go Daddy!
While we're at it why do registrars have the right to mass register thousands of 'valueless' domains everyday only to dump them within five days without penalty if they decide they don't want them? That's for another day though!