It might depend on where it was registered.
Whether it depends on where it was registered, depends also on whether it is already in the drop cycle. If it is already in "Redemption Grace Period", I don't think where it is registered has any bearing on where to catch it.
Also, of the three or four main domain catchers, none is "best" in the sense that they always win.
They might be best in that they catch 30% of the good drops, whereas the next best only catches 26% of the good drops.
It is also complicated by the fact that the "best" catcher varies from week to week, and even from day to day.
If you want a good domain name, the best thing to do is to use *all* the decent services.