Hello William,
there was not much insight with fish.us, simply in my country Iceland, fish is THE thing and has made our country one of the richest on the planet so fish should not be underestimated
When it comes to your name I do not have the same angle there to base an appraisal, however the word gets over 4 million sites on google and the meaning of the word has to do with the internets most popular or finding a mate, interacting with other people.
The name alone can get you some $K but if you develope it and create traffic to it which should not be to hard, the value will increase dramatically based on the traffic, and I think you know this as well as I.
Anyway, dont sell cheap, I stick to my good names untill I get what I can accept, otherwise I keep them. Put you price on it like $10,000 or what ever you feel is the right price- and stick to it as minimum, then dont rush.
I have sold many names, none under $2000 yet and up to $30,000 and that one was sold 1998, before the rush, could have got 10 times that in the rush At the moment I am promotin
www.CamPhone.com - I put my price on it and I have alrady a few good offers over $10K dont want to say exactly, in here I get appraisals for a few hundred $, but I intend to sell over $50K, so what others say and what I say doesnt matter, the buyer has the say.
Good luck,
Olafur