Is "online" a good long-term prefix or suffix? Will it be as common in 5 years, or 10?
Right now it makes good sense to me, and I hear "online" said many times each day if I pay attention...Therefore, I'd say that the online doesn't hinder the domain's valuation being that it's very common.
I do think the .net does diminish some of the value though.
I'd peg this one at $2500, based mostly on commercial potential. I think it would make sense as either a news, dating or general portal for the N.Y. area. I haven't taken a look to see if it's already developed.