I think many of us are trying to give facts about IDNs. Many of us invest in languages of different countries. We all believe adaptation will occur at different times.
IE7 was the biggest thing holding the whole market back. We all invested before IE7 was released to acquire premium domains.
As far as what makes me know if people will adapt to using IDNs (Applies to the Japanese market from my personal experience)
1. Japan has reduced the price of IDN dot jp to many registries to less than $10 just to get people to develop & it's working I read Japanese bloggers write about getting new domains for their blogs.
2. The Japanese search Engines (Google, Yahoo & Goo) made press releases early in the year that they are IDN compatible, when I started buying a year ago IDN domains showed as punycode.
3. Japanese in Japan don't type in URLs because they are bad at spelling in English (I think this is a worldwide known fact) they type the domain or site name in Japanese to search for it. I've watched every single Japanese person I know in Japan do this.
Many don't know about IDNs yet we all know this. After IDN sites are developed people realize they are available. We know full well it's not a quick return, just like people who invested in domains in 1995 or 1996. Were they getting the offers they could get now?
Many companies already have IDNs Microsoft, Coca Cola, Nike, Adidas, Yahoo, most of the Japanese financial companies etc. These companies have kept some of the best IDNs for their market for years. They didn't do it because they thought it was a fad, they kept them because they realize these are the best way for Japanese to access their brand, or products.
The same ideas that apply in English, Apply in other languages.
We are not trying to convert people, most of us just don't want to see inaccurate stereotypes about what we invest in.
Most technologies are working hard towards being IDN domain friendly.
People who are not comfortable with English can always see the benefit,
It's only people who are comfortable in English that sometimes think it's not going to be useful.
Interesting. Some basic information I didn't know or hadn't thought of. Thanks. If the Duck and you could keep from slamming the US and just present these types of information tidbits, what you say would be easier to absorb.