* To Don Giovanni --
Your appraisals are not brutal, they are just really stupid. Why on earth would Melvista sell guns.com for 10k if he's been offered 100k? Did you not read his comment that the name makes 50k on type-in traffic alone? Did you not know that the current overture bid for the keyword "guns" is 21 cents? Given that he gets 4000 type-ins a day, it could get a potential $800 of revenue a day (if we go by the overture)! At $800/day, it would take less than 2 weeks to make the supposed $10k that you claim this domain is worth.
* To gregr --
I'm sorry, but weaponry.com is not worth 99/100 of weapons.com.
* To izroot --
You claim that Melvista has an
"elitest attitude" and says that "all of [gregr's] names suck". Maybe you should actually read Melvista's posts before you disparage his name.
Here is what Melvista actually said:
I looked at the domains you have listed on your site and none even come close to GUNS.COM and I'm not saying this because I take pride in my domain, I'm comparing the traffic.
I think that Melvista is being very polite here. He is not saying that gregr's domains "suck", but that they don't compare to his "traffic".
P.S
As for Melvista being a troll, I'm going to assume that he isn't one. I typically see DnForum as an honest board free from that kind of behavior. Or maybe I'm just naive. And even if he is a troll, it doesn't matter in my opinion, because it's fun to give appraisals on these kinds of domains!